Cheese, Butter, and Eggs Are Good for You

Health authorities and dietary guidelines have told us for years to avoid high-fat animal foods like cheese, butter, and eggs. Science, however, is catching up to the fact that these ancestral foods are healthy.

High-fat dairy for better health

The latest research bombshell showed that there was no association between dairy fats and ill health. Serial measures of circulating biomarkers of dairy fat and total and cause-specific mortality in older adults: the Cardiovascular Health Study.

It also showed that higher intake was associated with a 42% lower risk of stroke.

Of course, correlation doesn’t equal causation, weak epidemiology, etc.

But if dairy fat caused cardiovascular disease or other chronic disease, we would see an association. And we don’t.

High-fat dairy foods are also associated with a lower rate of colon cancer. “Each increment of 2 servings of high-fat dairy foods/d corresponded to a 13% reduction in the risk of colorectal cancer.”

High-fat dairy like cheese and butter is associated with less obesity.

The observational evidence does not support the hypothesis that dairy fat or high-fat dairy foods contribute to obesity or cardiometabolic risk, and suggests that high-fat dairy consumption within typical dietary patterns is inversely associated with obesity risk.

So, cheese, butter, cream, yogurt, and other high-fat dairy products do not cause cardiovascular disease, and may protect against colorectal cancer, stroke, and obesity.

Eggs are healthy

Our establishment has also demonized eggs. Is there any basis for their claims that eggs are n ot healthy?

There is no association between egg consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes. Despite what the “plant-based” advocates will tell you. Current evidence suggests that there is no cause for concern regarding eggs and diabetes.

In type 2 diabetics on a weight-loss diet, consumption of a high amount of eggs did not adversely affect cardiometabolic markers.

Other studies have found that eating eggs improves cardiometabolic markers: insulin sensitivity and lipid markers were better when eating eggs.

Eating eggs increases HDL (“good”) cholesterol.

Why have we been mislead?

Denigrating cheese, butter, and eggs came about as a natural consequence of the establishment denigrating saturated fat, of which high-fat dairy products contain a lot, as do eggs.

But as we now know, saturated fat does not cause cardiovascular disease.

It all started with Ancel Keys and others trying to find out what was causing the heart disease epidemic.

But, as Nina Teicholz has argued, Keys was not only mistaken but was dishonest.

Cigarettes, sugar, and seed oils are arguably far more responsible for heart disease and all the other chronic diseases we have now. We figured out cigarettes, but seed oils and sugar are still given a pass.

Health authorities won’t embrace low-carbohydrate diets, or diets high in animal foods, because it would ruin their saturated fat narrative. They care more about never admitting that they were wrong than about your health.

Conclusion

For good health and protection against obesity, cardiovascular disease, and cancer, eat cheese, butter and eggs.

Also yogurt and sour cream, and other high-fat dairy products.

Eat eggs.

Also meat and fish.

Do not eat ultra-processed foods, which contain the deadly combo of seed oils, sugar, and refined grains.

PS: If you need to lose weight and you want to save yourself years of poor results with bad information, I’ve put everything in a simple guide for you.

The World’s Simplest Fat-Loss Plan.

 

image_pdfimage_print

Leave a Comment:

39 comments
Rob says July 24, 2018

Unfortunately, we are still being misled. Some folks on some of the internet health forums I read are touting this new study as “proof” that dietary fat is the cause of obesity (and that low carb diets therefore do not work for weight loss). There are at least a couple big problems with this study (and probably more….I have not reviewed it closely yet): 1) the study was done on mice, not humans; and 2) I believe the fats they fed the mice were at least partly sunflower oil, which is not exactly a healthy fat. If others get a chance to review the study (including you, P.D.), I would be interested in your take on it. Here’s the link:
https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/fulltext/S1550-4131(18)30392-9

Reply
    Morgana says July 25, 2018

    Rob: If I may- that study was done on mice, not humans. Mice are not adapted to eat as much fat as we are, and therefore will get fat.

    Reply
Nitpicking pedant says July 24, 2018

You have a typo here:
“Why have we been mislead?”

should be misled.

Reply
    Bill says July 25, 2018

    Misled only in the USA and English speakers in the Philippines..All other English speaking countries write ‘mislead’.

    Reply
      Nick says July 30, 2018

      Not so. In UK English also, ‘misled’ is the past tense of the verb ‘mislead’.

      Reply
Nina Perino says July 24, 2018

Wow the dairy and meat industry is really desperate! This is a load of bullshit and probably paid for by those Industries.

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 24, 2018

    Where do I get my check?

    Reply
    John says July 24, 2018

    Was thinking the same thing why should anyone believe this recycling of misinformation to keep hardworking people lining money hungry industries, alot more young people are going for a
    Vegan whole food plant based diet seeing the benefits it has on one’s health and environment not to mention the animals that are saved.

    Reply
      mark sanders says July 25, 2018

      I know quite a few vegans who, if they are healthy, certainly don’t look so. They look years and years older than they are and a few of them look like they’re next to death’s door.

      Reply
      Jeff says July 26, 2018

      Most qualified studies from universities like Harvard and Yale have been saying for years now that a total.vegan diet is no different than having an all meat diet. They both suffer the same amount of deficiencies. The people who have the longest life spans are the people who eat in moderation and stay away from all processed foods. Vegans and vegetarians are just radical narcisists. You don’t see meat eaters out protesting and ranting about others eating habits. Keep denying your body of certain foods is dangerous to your health and it is proven in the studies by these non-political entities.

      Reply
Virginia says July 24, 2018

All anyone has to do to find out what is actually good or bad for you just need to go to a nutritionist doctor. They know food WAY better than the other doctors, who know human biology, but not food.

Reply
Will says July 24, 2018

Still awful for animals though.

Reply
    Drifter says July 25, 2018

    You might want to consider a more balanced view. Have you ever worked on a (fairly traditional) farm or raised chickens near predators? If I’m a cow or a chicken I will happily trade milk and eggs in return for protection from predators and medical care when I need it. I found the farm I worked on to have a sense of peace and beauty and I would recommend visiting one if you have the chance.

    Reply
Joshua Choiniere says July 24, 2018

Funny how there’s no mention of cholesterol anywhere in this

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 24, 2018

    Why would there be? Dietary cholesterol doesn’t affect serum cholesterol, which in turn doesn’t cause heart disease.

    Reply
pzo says July 24, 2018

One man’s story does not make scientific proof, but: Age 72, eaten eggs almost every day of my life. In the last decade, got rid of seed oils and their margarines. Never shied from meat or dairy.

Lipid panels that would make a twenty something cry in jealousy. And, as an indictment of the medical establishment, my doctor wanted to put me on a statin! I will be looking for a new doc.

Reply
Mike says July 24, 2018

Who paid for this stupid advertisement…the dairy industry…go chug a pound of butter you idiots and see how good you feel after that. Just about the most ridiculous article I have read today.

Reply
Morgana says July 24, 2018

High fat dairy contains vitamin K2, which is very important for heart health; (and it is ONLY in high fat, not in low fat dairy). Unfortunately, the dietary guidelines really messed things up considerably; by not eating the right fats, not only were we not getting enough K2, but we were also lacking all the other important fat soluble vitamins- (like vitamins D, A and E). The study of nutrition is still basically in its infancy, and by jumping to conclusions and making recommendations before enough was known, it has caused more harm than good.

Reply
Fan says July 24, 2018

Man, this breaks my heart. It’s sad people who really aren’t an authority on nutrition who cherry pick articles to match what they feel is right. Sit with a doctor that actually treats people and reverses their disease based on eating whole foods and plant based. It is the only diet ever proven to reverse disease. It can do more than any drug out there. But people still continue to be prejudice and lead to confusion because they refuse to even consider the possibility that plants can really save lives.

Reply
Watch_geek says July 24, 2018

Eating a lot of high fats will always cause obesity which will lead to many health problems.
Also dairy contains casomorphines. This is because it’s a cow mother’s milk intented for calves. It helps to calm babies down and help them grow. I feel like this article was a justified piece pulled out of someone’s ass.

Reply
    Watch_geek says July 24, 2018

    Intended*

    Reply
    Thinker says July 26, 2018

    Eating a lot of high fats will always cause obesity which will lead to many health problems.

    Inuit traditionally lived almost entirely on fats and had no obesity, no diabetes, no heart attacks. Only when they move into government housing and begin eating SAD do those problems show up.

    Please explain this.

    Reply
David Fairclough says July 25, 2018

This study goes against almost every other current study ever done and lacks much logic and basic understanding of nutritioal understaning.
Do some research online and you will see this study has no true value

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 25, 2018

    Do try to keep up with current science, David.

    Reply
Bill says July 25, 2018

Bugger ! You have stirred the possum with the vegans here PD.. But I guess they need it occasionally to give them an opportunity to rethink things based on the the current evidence.

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 25, 2018

    Yeah it’s weird. They can only say something along the lines of “everyone knows that’s wrong”, or “you’re in the pay of meat and dairy industries” when faced with evidence contrary to their beliefs.

    Reply
      Morgana says July 25, 2018

      I find it fascinating to observe how emotional they are in these interchanges.

      Reply
        P. D. Mangan says July 25, 2018

        Yes, all emotion, very little logic. Insults too.

        Reply
Paul says July 26, 2018

They came in droves! Basically every comment was regarding how wrong you are. I imagine one person shared the article with the rest of them and they all felt the need to comment.

Reply
Thinker says July 26, 2018

You must be getting linked more widely, I do not recall this sort of emotion two years ago. A lot of people still have an emotional link to 1960’s research? The vegetarian / vegans are like cultists whose guru has been insulted.

Keep up the good work!

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 27, 2018

    Thanks, Thinker. I’m not sure what happens but it looks like I may get picked up by Google News or some type of Google alert. That happened when I wrote about “plant-based” and the traffic literally shut down my site. I believe something similar happened with this article.

    Reply
Dave says July 28, 2018

Mr Mangan,

Your article essentially discusses foods that have been consumed in quantity across Europe for centuries successfully and with populations that were not obese or generally fat throughout their lives, so I’d say that it’s on the ball as per usual. It’s funny how foods that worked well for so long have been so demonized in the last 100 years in-spite of this.

I’d also ignore all the vegetarian critics and their emotional breakdowns too!

Regards

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 28, 2018

    Thanks, Dave. Yes, foods that humans have eaten for a long time couldn’t be responsible for modern diseases.

    Reply
Raj says July 31, 2018

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30022800

What are your thoughts.

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says July 31, 2018

    No mention of ultra-processed foods, with sugar, seed oils, and refined carbs, consumption of which has increased vastly in China and the rest of the world.

    Reply
john says August 2, 2018

anyone who has read the book “Cholesterol Myths” knows that this story is not a big surprise….The Masai of Africa & the Samburu eat 3-10 lbs of meat per day and had absolutely no atherosclerosis when George Mann studied them in the 50’s or 60’s. The Masai only consume meat, milk & blood and run every day. They are violent, raiding neighboring tribes and capturing females and livestocks but the point is that these 2 tribes utterly decimate the cholesterol/lipid hypothesis. Vegan do not read books unless that are certified post-fact friendly. just like horses wearing Blinders down 6th avenue

Reply
jre says September 6, 2018

Just some food for thought to support a low carb, high fat and protein diet.

https://www.biologicalpsychiatryjournal.com/article/S0006-3223(18)31793-1/fulltext

BCAA supplementation or high protein diet has been used in mouse models (24) and human patients (31) with BCKDK deficiency to successfully reduce ASD (autism spectrum disorder) symptoms and improve cognitive function.

Looking through the literature, we see low carb, high protein being addressed as having value in ‘certain situation.’ We also know keto diets help with seizures.

On some level, parents of adhd boys (and I don’t think its adhd but rather the educational system- but that is another discussion) anecdotally report cutting sugar (ie carbs) helped their children.

Reply
Add Your Reply