New study finds that antioxidants hamper exercise adaptation

vitamin C exercise

A number of studies have found that taking antioxidant vitamins, namely vitamins C and E, hampers or blocks the physiological adaptation to exercise. However, other studies have not, so we have a state of conflicting information in this area. (You can read some of the background and other studies here.) Three of the most important exercise adaptations are increased VO2 max (better utilization of oxygen), increased mitochondria (the powerhouses of the cell), and better insulin sensitivity. Obviously you want these adaptations; these are the main reasons why exercise makes one healthy.

The adaptations to exercise depend upon the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) during exercise. ROS act as cellular signals, upon which the cell’s machinery to generate the adaptations is turned on or up. Since these signals are oxidants, it follows that antioxidants, such as vitamins C and E, might very well block them to the extent that their signalling power is rendered null, or at least diminished.

As mentioned, there are conflicting studies on this. Some of the studies that found that adaptations were blocked by C and E have been criticized on methodological grounds.

Along comes a new study to try to clarify our knowledge on antioxidants and exercise: Vitamin C and E supplementation hampers cellular adaptation to endurance training in humans: a double‐blind, randomised, controlled trial.

Key points

  • Recent studies have indicated that antioxidant supplementation may blunt adaptations to exercise, such as mitochondrial biogenesis induced by endurance training. However, studies in humans are sparse and results are conflicting.

  • Isolated vitamin C and E supplements are widely used, and unravelling the interference of these vitamins in cellular and physiological adaptations to exercise is of interest to those who exercise for health purposes and to athletes.

  • Our results show that vitamin C and E supplements blunted the endurance training‐induced increase of mitochondrial proteins (COX4), which is important for improving muscular endurance.

  • Training‐induced increases in Formula and running performance were not detectably affected by the supplementation.

  • The present study contributes to understanding of how antioxidants may interfere with adaptations to exercise in humans, and the results indicate that high dosages of vitamins C and E should be used with caution.

So, add this study to the list of positive results: vitamins C and E diminish the physiological adaptations to exercise.

As a practical matter, what does this mean for one who exercises? A hint can be found in the discussion section of the article:

Our observations conflict with findings in a recent human study by Yfanti et al. (2010), who reported that supplementation with vitamin C and E did not alter training adaptations… A plausible explanation for this discrepancy could be that Yfanti et al. (2010) used a vitamin C supplement of 500 mg day−1, rather than the 1000 mg day−1 used in the present study. Furthermore, our participants were instructed to take the supplements in two doses (half dosage: 500 mg vitamin C and 117.5 mg vitamin E) 1–3 h before and within 1 h after each exercise session. By contrast, participants in the study by Yfanti et al. (2010) consumed their vitamin supplement only at breakfast. Given the pharmacokinetics of vitamin C in plasma [which decrease within a few hours], this might have caused a different cellular response to the supplementation.

It looks to me that the key here is not to take vitamin C in the few hours around exercise, and that may very well be enough to negate its effects on exercise.

I intend to continue to take vitamin C in under 1 gram amounts, but not around workouts. However, it certainly does appear that the common practice of athletes of taking large amounts of antioxidant vitamins is counterproductive.

image_pdf

Leave a Comment:

9 comments
the Revision Division says October 27, 2014

[…] YOU CAN USE: New study finds that antioxidants hamper exercise adaptation. “Our results show that vitamin C and E supplements blunted the endurance training‐induced […]

Reply
DdR says October 27, 2014

Hi Dennis,

This very well may be true, but I feel that if I supplement with Vitamin C before I go to bed (1,000mg, sustained release), my mood, well-being, erections, stamina, blood sugar, etc., are much better than the previous day. I had stopped supplementing Vitamin C for a while because of the reports that it hampers the benefits from exercise, so I could tell right away the difference when I began supplementing again. I will follow your advice and supplement Vitamin C well past the time I exercised.

I also ingest about a tsp of wheat germ oil to get my minimum intake of Vitamin E per day. It’s not much, I believe 7 mg, but I found that it was virtually impossible for me to ingest my RDA in Vitamin E unless I ate a ton of whole-wheat bread or five cups of spinach. I don’t buy into high doses of Vitamin C, unless they’re mixed tocopherols.

How do you feel about supplementing Vitamin C with real food, e.g., camu camu, versus the ascorbic-acid stuff produced primarily in China? I’ve seen a number of people arguing (naturally w/o any actual evidence) that the synthetic Vitamin C kills off some of the beneficial bacteria in your gut. Nonetheless, I’ve been ingesting camu camu more lately. The stuff tastes vile.

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says October 29, 2014

    DdR: thanks for that, interesting that you can feel the difference with C. Perhaps I should try to supplement more diligently. Also, agree that only mixed tocopherols should ever be supplemented for E, not the artificial stuff. C ought to be the same no matter it’s provenance, though contaminants might be an issue.

    Reply
Bryan says November 5, 2014

Do you have a sense if Vitamin C supplementation may diminish the benefits of fasting in a similar way?
I take Vit C fasted – and with caffeine – based on this idea: http://www.longecity.org/forum/topic/74292-vitamin-c-completely-enhances-caffeine-for-caffeine-sensitive-people-for-nootropic-effect/ … but if I am diminishing benefits of fasting (much like taking after exercise), I will stop doing that.

Also, what kind of time threshold are you thinking with a “few hours”? 3? Does this apply to before and after exercise?

p.s. LOVE the blog and follow it religiously (whether I comment or not)

Reply
    P. D. Mangan says November 5, 2014

    Bryan, I’m not sure, but I think the possibility exists that C may interfere with IF. However, IF does not depend on reactive oxygen species, which C negates. The only thing really solid I know there is that in C. elegans, glucose restriction prolongs life, but this longevity is abolished by antioxidants. Since glucose restriction is a form of fasting (CR), there is some basis for thinking that C might interfere with IF.

    By a few hours, yes, 3 sounds about right, and I think before or after will be OK. Key is to have the C be completely absorbed and taken up by cells before exercise begins.

    Sincerely appreciate that you love the blog, thanks! I will endeavor to keep posting interesting material.

    Reply
The military school of health and long life - Rogue Health and Fitness says February 2, 2015

[…] Antioxidants can abolish the health-promoting effects of exercise. The reason that they do this – or possibly could do this, research is ongoing – is because they abolish the cellular signals, ROS, that indicate that a stress is being placed on the body. No stress, no adaptation. […]

Reply
Supplement Timing - Rogue Health and Fitness says March 8, 2015

[…] times here, both fasting and calorie restriction promote longevity. But antioxidants may not only abolish the health effects of exercise, but also abolish the health effects of calorie restriction and intermittent fasting. In this […]

Reply
Haven M. says June 17, 2015

any thoughts on astaxanthin?

Reply
The Downside of Antioxidants - Rogue Health and Fitness says August 1, 2016

[…] or abolishing free radicals produced by exercise means blunting or abolishing its healthful effects. Exercise absolutely depends on the generation of free radicals to improve health. Vitamins C and […]

Reply
Add Your Reply